Right on.

actually I pretty much hate Dirty, sorry I can't be cool.

It's ok

I know, I said I was sorry.

I like dirty! Hope that doesn't offend anyone...

I've never thought about this and it hurts my head to do so... out of everything I've got... I think....

1. Sister
2. EVOL
3. Washing Machine
4. Sonic Nurse
5. Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
6. Goo
7. Bad Moon Rising
8. The Destroyed Room
9. Rather Ripped
10. Murray Street
11. Daydream Nation
12. A Thousand Leaves
13. Dirty
14. NYC Ghost & Flowers

Sister
DDN
BMR
Washing Machine
Nurse
Evol
CIS/KYI
Goo
Murray Street
ATL
EJSTNS
NYCG+F
RR
Dirty

Every album is good though.

ive never been able to answer a question like this, but if i was to group albums id go...

Top Class:
Daydream Nation
Murray Street
Bad Moon Rising
Evol

Class:
Confusion is sex
Sonic Nurse
Goo
Evol
NYC G n F

Very good:
Sister
Dirty
SYR1
Silver sessions
Whitey Album

Enjoyable:
Rather Ripped
A thousand Leaves
Sonic Youth

Acceptable but not amazing
Washing Machine
Experimental Jet Set

1. EVOL
2. Washing Machine
3. Murray Street
4. Daydream Nation
5. Bad Moon Rising
6. NYCGF
7. Sister
8. Goo
9. Dirty
10. A Thousand Leaves
11. Confusion is Sex / Kill yr idols
12. Sonic Nurse
13. Made in USA
14. Rather Ripped
15. EJSTANS

1. Sister
2. EVOL
10. Washing Machine
6. Sonic Nurse
3. Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
9. Goo
4. Bad Moon Rising
11. The Destroyed Room
7. Rather Ripped
8. Murray Street
5. Daydream Nation
13. A Thousand Leaves
12. Dirty
14. NYC Ghost & Flowers

This is going to be hard, but lets see...

I can only do a top 5. The rest are all great too and i can't really put them in order....

1. Daydream Nation
2. EVOL
3. Sonic Nurse
4. Sister
5. Dirty

I think this once already but...

1- daydream nation
2- Evol
3- Sister
4- Bad Moon Rising
5- Confusion is Sex
6- Goo
7- Sonic youth
8- Ciccone Youth
9- Dirty
10- Thousand Leaves
11- Sonic Nurse
12- Rather Ripped
13- Murray Street
14- Washing machine
15- NYC Ghost & Flowers
.
.
.
.
.
100- Experimental jet Set Trash & No Star

Why does everyone prefer Dirty to EJSTNS?

[quote=ZEROpumpkins]Why does everyone prefer Dirty to EJSTNS?[/quote

I rank it one spot better.


new list

1. Sister
2. Daydream Nation
3. Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
4. Bad Moon Rising
5. Goo
6. Sonic Nurse
7. Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star
8. Washing Machine
9. Evol
10. Dirty
11. Murray Street
12. NYC Ghosts and Flowers
13. A Thousand Leaves
14. Rather Ripped
15. Sonic Youth

You don't like the EP?

dirty has wish fulfilment, 100%, JC, chapel hill, purr, orange rolls angels spit, etc.

I just do not like listening to EJST&NS

1. Daydream Nation
2. Washing Machine
3. Murray St.
4. Goo
5. NYCGF
6. Sister
7. The Destroyed Room
8. Sonic Youth
9. Dirty
10. Sonic Nurse
11. Evol
12. CIS
13. ATL
14. Bad Moon
15. Exp
16. Rather Ripped

1. Evol
2. Goo
3. Confusion is sex
4. Daydream nation
5. Rather ripped
6. Bad moon rising
7. Sonic nurse
8. Murray street
9. Sonic youth
10. Dirty
11. Experimental jet set trash and no star
12. A thousand leaves
13. Sister
14. Washing machine
15. Sonic death
16. Nyc ghosts and flowers

1. Sister
2. Daydream Nation
3. Evol
4. Bad Moon Rising
5. Sonic Nurse
6. Murray Street
7. Confusion is Sex / Kill Yr Idols
8. Goo
9. Dirty
10. Washing Machine
11. A Thousand Leaves
12. NYC Ghosts and Flowers
13. Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star
14. Sonic Youth
15. Rather Ripped

1. Daydream Nation
2. Sister
3. Dirty
4. A thousand leaves
5. S/T
6. Goo
7. Evol
8. Murray street
9. EJST&NS
10. Sonic nurse
11. Washing machine
12. NYCG&F
13. Bad moon rising
14. CIS/KYI
15. Rather ripped

completely unscientific, and by personal preference

1. Jet Set
2. Dirty
3. Washing Machine
4. ATL
5. DDN
6. Sister
7. Goo
8. CIS with Kill Yr Idols
9. Murray Street
10. Nurse
11. Rather Ripped
12. BMR
13. EVOL
14. NYC G&F
15. Sonic Youth

daydream nation/sister (tied for 1st)
evol
kill yr idols/confusion
goo
nurse
dirty
bad moon rising
sonic youth
to hell with all their other records

1. Sister
2. Washing Machine
3. Daydream Nation
4. Dirty
5. EVOL
6. Goo
7. A Thousand Leaves
8. Murray Street
9. Confusion Is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
10. Bad Moon Rising
11. Sonic Nurse
12. EJST&NS
13. NYC Ghosts and Flowers
14. Rather Ripped
15. Sonic Youth

1. Daydream Nation
2. Confusion is Sex/ Kill Your Idols
3. Dirty
4. Sonic Nurse
5. Goo
6.Bad Moon Rising
7. Sister
8. Evol
9. Rather Ripped
10. Washing Machine
11. Murray Street
12. EJST&NS
13. A Thousand Leaves
14. Sonic Youth
15. NYC Ghosts and Flowers

I love the ep, (I love them all) but something has to bring up the rear.

1.)Sister
2.)Washing Machine
3.)Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
4.)BMR
5.)Daydream Nation
6.)Goo
7.)NYC G&F
8.)Dirty
9.)Rather Ripped
10.)EVOL
11.)Sonic Nurse
12.)Murray Street
13.)EJSTNS
14.)A thousand Leaves
But, I really love A thousand leaves (except a few songs) or EJSTNS, there is no weak album in my list, it's just maybe, those I listen the most and those I listen less...

Daydream Nation
EVOL
Sonic Nurse
Dirty
Confusion Is Sex
Goo
Washine Machine
Sister
A Thousand Leaves
Murray Street
Experimental Jet Set
Rather Ripped
Sonic Youth
Bad Moon Rising
NYC Ghosts and Flowers

Id like to promote Nurse to the top tier, because it kicks the tits off of the other SY albums around that period.

01 - NYC Ghosts & Flowers
02 - Bad Moon Rising
03 - Sonic Nurse
04 - EVOL
05 - 1000 Leaves
06 - Sonic Youth
07 - Sister
08 - Washing Machine
09 - Confusion Is Sex
10 - Daydream Nation
11 - Dirty
12 - Experimental Jet Set
13 - Murray Street
14 - Goo
15 - Rather Ripped

I don't know if this list is representative, cause i like every release in some kind of way (Rather Ripped is the only stabile thing in the list, tho i love Pink Steam; and the first three places will always be on top, even if their position is changing sometime between them)

1. Evol
2. Daydream Nation
3. Sister
4. Bad Moon Rising
5. Confusion is Sex(/KYI)
6. Murray Street
7. Goo
8. Washing Machine
9. A Thousand Leaves
10. Sonic Nurse
11. Dirty
12. NYC Ghosts and Flowers
13. Experimental Jet-Set
14. Rather Ripped

not including s/t... not sure where it would be... Maybe after Murray Street.

1. Dirty
2. Rather Ripped
The rest in any order behind the MIGHTY TWO.

Surely you jest.

I haven't listened to all of the albums, so this is my top 5
1.Daydream Nation
2.EVOL
3.Sister
4.Sonic Youth
5.Dirty

Don't worry, you have the three best ones.

Are the 3 best ones DDN, EVOL and Sister?

am i the only one that thinks dirty isn't that good?

I didn't like Dirty when I first heard it, because I wanted to hear something that sounded like Daydream Nation.
I can see why some people don't like it. There are some songs on there that aren't very good.

1. daydream nation
2. evol
3. bad moon rising
4. jet set
5. sister
6. s/t
7. a thousand leaves
8. confusion is sex
9. nyc ghosts and flowers
10. goo
11. murray street
12. washing machine
13. sonic nurse
14. dirty
15. rather ripped

Nope, I agree with you.

I like rather ripped a lot more than most people and DDN less... It's hard to say. I try and judge it on how likely i am to put it on.