Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonics (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   What book should I read next? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=26384)

DeadDiscoDildo 10.04.2008 02:54 PM

read the traveler damnit!

I have noone to talk to about it on these boards!

Kloriel 10.07.2008 08:17 PM

also don't fucking spoil endings. i'm not saying someone did but i started reading a post and then its direction was headed towards here is the end and i said oh fuck out loud to my pet iguana Yogurt who didn't even blink and so i mashed keys until the back button was hit. Yogurt is doing fine though.

Sonic Youth 37 10.07.2008 08:20 PM

Aiming to finish Brave New World and start/finish Call of Cthulhu tonight with some trying to read my 1,200 or so pages for my Greek History Mid-term tomorrow.

uhler 10.08.2008 12:52 AM

i'm mostly reading zines nowadays, but i just started snow crash and it's pretty great so far.

i picked the divine comedy. great book.

pbradley 10.08.2008 01:13 AM

Read some Platonic dialogues.

Sonic Youth 37 10.08.2008 01:30 AM

So, I finished both those tonight. So, over the my 4-day break, I intend to read Dracula, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, The Time Machine, and Cannery Row.

tesla69 10.08.2008 08:39 AM

Lovecraft, but really you should run not walk and find Jim Marrs' new one The Rise of the Fourth Reich. Fascinating stuff, I've already learned the uranium used in the nukes, if not the nukes themselves, dropped on Japan probably came from the Nazis, and the Germans probably used nukes against the Soviets.

!@#$%! 10.08.2008 11:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37
So, I finished both those tonight.


brave new world was underwhelming, wasn't it?

Sonic Youth 37 10.08.2008 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
brave new world was underwhelming, wasn't it?


Very. I wasn't expecting it to come close to 1984 at all, but I wasn't expecting it to be like it was. I will not be recommending it to anyone.

Glice 10.08.2008 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pbradley
Read some Platonic dialogues.


See, I would argue that there are some things that there's no essential need to read. Plato's writing is so entrenched in large slews of Western philosophy that you don't even need to read him. Nietzsche, yes. Plato, no. There's a few subtleties and nuances that you'll miss without reading Plato, but you're life won't be enriched any by ploughing through. Seneca's Medea, that's what you want.

!@#$%! 10.08.2008 09:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
See, I would argue that there are some things that there's no essential need to read. Plato's writing is so entrenched in large slews of Western philosophy that you don't even need to read him. Nietzsche, yes. Plato, no. There's a few subtleties and nuances that you'll miss without reading Plato, but you're life won't be enriched any by ploughing through. Seneca's Medea, that's what you want.


see, but i'd argue that reading plato is necessary to know the enemy & where he came from.

seneca's medea? i had never heard of that. hm, that got me interested...

pbradley 10.08.2008 10:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
See, I would argue that there are some things that there's no essential need to read. Plato's writing is so entrenched in large slews of Western philosophy that you don't even need to read him. Nietzsche, yes. Plato, no. There's a few subtleties and nuances that you'll miss without reading Plato, but you're life won't be enriched any by ploughing through. Seneca's Medea, that's what you want.

I think that is quite ridiculous. Should you be so content to read the footnotes of a book instead the book itself in order to save time? I would say the legs of the table are the most essential element to the structure of a table yet you seem to suggest that they are not because the table apparently already stands. Nietzsche himself can be found in the character of Callicles in the Gorgias!

Sonic Youth 37 10.08.2008 10:17 PM

I'm staying away from ancient texts at the moment because I'm currently up to my ass in Herodotus, Thucydides, and Tacitus

Glice 10.09.2008 03:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pbradley
I think that is quite ridiculous. Should you be so content to read the footnotes of a book instead the book itself in order to save time? I would say the legs of the table are the most essential element to the structure of a table yet you seem to suggest that they are not because the table apparently already stands. Nietzsche himself can be found in the character of Callicles in the Gorgias!


I think the table metaphor is fine, but philosophy isn't a table. The root of Western epistemics isn't an object, it's manifested everywhere. I'm not saying one shouldn't read Plato, but as he's everywhere already, you don't really need to rush to read him.

pbradley 10.09.2008 03:37 AM

Perhaps if you are already familiar with Western contemporary philosophy but most aren't. Either way SY 37 looks like he's already Greeking out and I'd probably agree with you if I weren't in the middle of this Plato seminar class.

Glice 10.09.2008 03:47 AM

Fair enough. I'm probably biased because I'd read odds and sods of philosophy before I got to Plato, and he seemed a bit tepid by that point. It was only a little bit later that his import struck me, but even so, it's probably the case that he's too important to consider seriously (he says contentiously) with 'new' eyes (although, obviously, there've been a few in the 20th-century who've tried).

Sonic Youth 37 10.12.2008 08:05 PM

I'm reading Dracula right now. I just realized that the courtyard is well-lit enough to read at night. Total win.

sticky money 10.12.2008 10:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
But wasn't there some reason why the didn't all die? What was the whole thing with the little girl and the pan-dimensional bird? Didn't that mean they didn't all die? And the watch? And the packet of matches?


The book of matches was from the club, on earth, that they were at right before the earth got destroyed. They assumed it was a planet, but were wrong unfortunately.

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 10.13.2008 12:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
i voted divine comedy for the simple reason that it's such a cornerstone of western literature that everyone should read & know it.


I voted for it as well for that reason

StevOK 10.13.2008 12:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
brave new world was underwhelming, wasn't it?


I liked it better the second time I read it.

acousticrock87 10.13.2008 01:12 AM

A Portrait.

Read what you want, but for the love of God don't read Dracula. That piece of shit was the biggest waste of time. The first 50 pages (Harker's Journal) are ace--essential reading, maybe. Then it's like getting slapped in the face by a frilly diary every single page.

Cthulu might be worth reading first, though, cause it's incredibly short. Unless you're setting aside the whole Penguin "And Other Weird Stories" thing or something, but I wouldn't read more than a few at a time.

acousticrock87 10.13.2008 01:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !@#$%!
i voted divine comedy for the simple reason that it's such a cornerstone of western literature that everyone should read & know it.

it's also a bridge between antiquity and modernity: a document of the budding renaissance. sure, some people will say it's still the middle ages, with its fucked theology and geocentric cosmology, but the resurrection of classical antiquity is a renaissance move. this is good shit.

read the inferno, and procure yourself good notes-- the details, the history and the explanation of each character, each myth, each legend, each symbol referenced or created are highly entertaining. his similes are epic-- hailing back to virgil and homer. but way cooler i think. here is where translation fails, especially verse translation-- you'll get better results with a prose translation and a look at the original italian verse.

the purgatory gets a bit dull-- by paradiso, dullness has set in, with all the fucking spinning spheres. but still-- good stuff.

poete maudit
e malcolm lowry attempted a XX century version of the divine comedy and failed at providing parts 2 & 3, but left us "under the volcano" which was made into an awesome movie by john huston with albert finney as geoffrey firmin-- black magician learning that karma is a bitch.

nietzsche, who saw dante as getting his petty revenge in writing when he couldn't defeat his enemies in real life, called him the hyena who versified among the graves. hyena or not, the man was thoroughly defeated, exiled, heartbroken, frustrated, and took refuge in poetry.

ezra pound makes frequent and constant reference to dante in his cantos.

in the spanish language (perhaps others too) the adjective dantesco is used to describe anything so horrible that defies human imagination, like a concentration camp or a battlefield.

anyway, get that in you and you'll be on solid ground to talk bullshit for many years to come.

the other books you mention are good, but none as essential as this.

Yeah, but I read it in translation--prosaic and poetic translations, with copious notes--and all I ever see are Italian references that I have to have translated/explained anyway. Its kind of a useless read if you don't know Italian, I think, and more tedious in English than is worth the effort.

You'd be better off learning Italian first if you're going to read Cantos. If you're planning on attacking something that intense, you're probably inclined enough to take the time. 'Real education must ultimately be limited to men who insist on knowing, the rest is mere sheep-herding.'

Sonic Youth 37 10.13.2008 01:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by acousticrock87
A Portrait.

Read what you want, but for the love of God don't read Dracula. That piece of shit was the biggest waste of time. The first 50 pages (Harker's Journal) are ace--essential reading, maybe. Then it's like getting slapped in the face by a frilly diary every single page.

Cthulu might be worth reading first, though, cause it's incredibly short. Unless you're setting aside the whole Penguin "And Other Weird Stories" thing or something, but I wouldn't read more than a few at a time.


I read 1/4 of A Portrait about 2 years ago as I was trying to read Ulysses the first time, then stopped reading it when I stopped reading Ulysses.

Call of Cthulhu was read in about an hour last week. It was great. I found a 3mb text file of Lovecraft on Project Gutenberg that I will make my way through in due time.

I read 90 pages of Dracula today. As you said, the first bit from Harker's diary is good, but the rest has been meh at best. Lucy and Mina's diaries and letters are boring me to tears.
Quote:

Originally Posted by acousticrock87
Yeah, but I read it in translation--prosaic and poetic translations, with copious notes--and all I ever see are Italian references that I have to have translated/explained anyway. Its kind of a useless read if you don't know Italian, I think, and more tedious in English than is worth the effort.

You'd be better off learning Italian first if you're going to read Cantos. If you're planning on attacking something that intense, you're probably inclined enough to take the time. 'Real education must ultimately be limited to men who insist on knowing, the rest is mere sheep-herding.'



The verse translation of Inferno (even with flipping to the explanation pages at least twice per page) is among my top 10 favorite things I've ever read.

deflinus 10.13.2008 02:11 AM

I just finished Gene Wilder's book Kiss Me Like A Stranger

i liked it a lot. very interesting read if you're a fan

Sonic Youth 37 10.13.2008 08:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deflinus
I just finished Gene Wilder's book Kiss Me Like A Stranger

i liked it a lot. very interesting read if you're a fan


Wow, I'll definitely be picking this up. Gene Wilder is probably one of my favorite actors ever.

acousticrock87 10.13.2008 03:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37
I read 1/4 of A Portrait about 2 years ago as I was trying to read Ulysses the first time, then stopped reading it when I stopped reading Ulysses.

Call of Cthulhu was read in about an hour last week. It was great. I found a 3mb text file of Lovecraft on Project Gutenberg that I will make my way through in due time.

I read 90 pages of Dracula today. As you said, the first bit from Harker's diary is good, but the rest has been meh at best. Lucy and Mina's diaries and letters are boring me to tears.


The verse translation of Inferno (even with flipping to the explanation pages at least twice per page) is among my top 10 favorite things I've ever read.

Yeah I've actually never read Portrait because of Ulysses. Still have a good 120 pages to go on that. I'm just assuming. It's the first thing I'm going to pick up when this monster is slain. Well, maybe after Absalom, Absalom--but I might read that before I finish Ulysses, anyway. I just don't want to read Portrait simultaneously. That would be kind of confusing, I think.

Everything by Lovecraft is more-or-less of equal quality. It's good to read a few at a time, though. Savor it throughout your life.

As for Inferno, I dunno. Maybe it's just me. I was really excited the first time I read it and got a nice leather-bound Harvard edition of the Divine Comedy, and I think I did enjoy it, but I was just a little disappointed. I was also just starting to get into literature so I may not have had the patience and training I needed. No doubt, it's one of the greatest works of all time, but from what I've heard from people that read it in the original, it's far more enjoyable untranslated, especially if reading it for the purpose of breaking into Eliot/Pound. I don't think the translation gives you quite the "tools" you need to pick up direct references. Either way, I didn't like it enough to continue to Purgatorio. Maybe I should read a more modern translation. And maybe skim through the first part of Machiavelli's History of Florence so I don't have to consult notes as much.

And Dracula: I kept waiting for it to get better and it never did. There are a few promised scenes, but they're brief and surrounded by boredom. Renfield is the sole reason I kept reading, but I'm not sure whether I'm glad I read it or not. I guess there's merit in reading everything, but it will be tedious.

Glice 10.13.2008 03:48 PM

Portrait is a very different book to Ulysses. I always give portrait to the sorts of people who would hate Joyce because of Finnegans Wake or Ulysses and it's generally well-received.

Sonic Youth 37 10.13.2008 03:49 PM

Part of why I liked the Inferno so much I do believe is that I read it about 6 months before I was going to Florence and the 3 or so days I was there I went Dante crazy. It was just a big thrill for me that I felt I needed to read all the Divine Comedy but lost interest halfway through Purgatory, then picked up Ulysses.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
Portrait is a very different book to Ulysses. I always give portrait to the sorts of people who would hate Joyce because of Finnegans Wake or Ulysses and it's generally well-received.


The reason I was reading it at the same time was because the copy of Ulysses I was reading, a previous reader had written a "How to read Ulysses" guide in the front blank pages and they suggested that if it was your first time reading Joyce that you read Portrait first, so I half-followed their anonymous advice and tried to read it at the same time, but graduated before I could make much headway into Ulysses and I had to return it.

deflinus 10.13.2008 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37
Wow, I'll definitely be picking this up. Gene Wilder is probably one of my favorite actors ever.


you'll definitely love it, man. im just a big fan of mel brooks, gene wilder, richard pryor. all of those really great comedies. Stir Crazy is seriously one of the most funniest movies i've ever seen. and he does talk about filming it in the book.

he's a really interesting guy. he has class. and he loves women.

Kallisti23chaos 10.13.2008 10:29 PM

"the alchemist" by paulo coehlo
"Illuminatus trilogy" by robert anton wilson

Kallisti23chaos 10.13.2008 10:32 PM

call of cthulhu too

Sonic Youth 37 10.13.2008 11:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deflinus
you'll definitely love it, man. im just a big fan of mel brooks, gene wilder, richard pryor. all of those really great comedies. Stir Crazy is seriously one of the most funniest movies i've ever seen. and he does talk about filming it in the book.

he's a really interesting guy. he has class. and he loves women.


I love all those Wilder/Pryor movies (yes, even See No Evil Hear No Evil) and I cannot watch Blazing Saddles while keeping a straight face for more than a few minutes.

Gene seems like a really ace guy. I'll have to make a special effort to get this.

evollove 10.14.2008 08:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sonic Youth 37
a previous reader had written a "How to read Ulysses" guide in the front blank pages and they suggested that if it was your first time reading Joyce that you read Portrait first


Ulysses is a sequel to Portrait.

Glice 10.14.2008 12:06 PM

That's an exceptionally tenuous sense of 'sequal', but not entirely inaccurate.

floatingslowly 10.14.2008 12:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pbradley
I think that is quite ridiculous. Should you be so content to read the footnotes of a book instead the book itself in order to save time?


isn't it hard to type q, a and z with yr pinkie finger up in the air like that?

Glice 10.14.2008 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by floatingslowly
isn't it hard to type q, a and z with yr pinkie finger up in the air like that?


You don't seem to have any problems typing with your whole head in a slightly darker place than the air.

lulz

floatingslowly 10.14.2008 12:59 PM

at least my head-space is still dark; yr's seems to be full o' sunshine, stretch.

lawl

EVOLghost 10.14.2008 06:27 PM

The Trial by Franz Kafka....

EVOLghost 10.14.2008 06:28 PM

Dracula is a good one too...

Sonic Youth 37 10.14.2008 06:30 PM

Today's purchases:

Complete Stories and Poems - Poe
The Hound of the Baskervilles - Doyle
The Doom that Came To Sarnath and Other Stories - Lovecraft

That was the only Lovecraft book they had :(


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:29 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth