Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonics (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   You guys wanna start a book club? (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=1928)

xpressway2yrskull 05.17.2006 06:21 AM

I think it's a great idea. So long as there's actually a decent number of people prepared to discuss afterwards.

Glice 05.17.2006 06:32 AM

I'm tentatively interested, because I have enjoyed the pleasures of a book club before.

I share Truncated's concerns, to some degree, but would also like to say that I suspect it'll be easier to get people to read Kundera than Stephen King. Something no-one has read would be quite difficult to find, but I would rather not have to suffer the ilk of either authors I have suggested here.

Perhaps we could start with Genesis, and work our way up from there?

truncated 05.17.2006 06:35 AM

I know you didn't just knock Stephen King.

I have had similar hallucinations regarding cheese villification on this board as well.

It must be me.

Glice 05.17.2006 06:37 AM

Read veneration where you feel it is wanted. I'm just waiting for the takers on the Kundera-bait to be honest.

truncated 05.17.2006 06:42 AM

I suppose I'm ambivalent toward Kundera, though I've only read "Unbearable Lightness."

I found him unnecessarily convoluted at times, and was basically unimpressed.

However, I'm open-minded. If someone can suggest a novel of his that will change my mind, I'd give it a go.

*Edit/disclaimer: Yes, I shorten album and book titles when writing them out. No, I do not use the appropriate ellipses or brackets. So piss off.

DemonBox 05.17.2006 06:46 AM

count me in. the library here is not so good, but i know they order stuff if i ask, it takes some time though.

Glice 05.17.2006 06:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truncated
I suppose I'm ambivalent toward Kundera, though I've only read "Unbearable Lightness."

I found him unnecessarily convoluted at times, and was basically unimpressed.

However, I'm open-minded. If someone can suggest a novel of his that will change my mind, I'd give it a go.

*Edit/disclaimer: Yes, I shorten album and book titles when writing them out. No, I do not use the appropriate ellipses or brackets. So piss off.


I get pissed off with him because every idiot and their dog keeps telling me I should read him... he's gone into that category of 'intellectual books for people who aren't very clever' (cf - On the Road). He's a distinctly average writer.

Now, can I get seconded in my proposition that people read something by Genet?

alyasa 05.17.2006 07:46 AM

King sets great mood, can I join? Reading Thomas Pynchon, first time; shocking...

TheDom 05.17.2006 07:52 AM

I'm in. Sounds cool.

umjammer atomsk 05.17.2006 08:21 AM

Sounds like it could be interesting. Reading a book a month then discussing. Cool, I'm in. As long as I can get copies of the books we're assigned, it'll be a sinch.

truncated 05.17.2006 08:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
I get pissed off with him because every idiot and their dog keeps telling me I should read him... he's gone into that category of 'intellectual books for people who aren't very clever' (cf - On the Road). He's a distinctly average writer.


I'll second that, at least.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glice
Now, can I get seconded in my proposition that people read something by Genet?


Are we talking Jean Genet? I've never read him, so I'd be up for that. Play or novel?

Glice 05.17.2006 08:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truncated
I'll second that, at least.



Are we talking Jean Genet? I've never read him, so I'd be up for that. Play or novel?


Either's good. I haven't read all of the books, and I wasn't aware there were plays. He is possibly a little difficult to get hold of (in the UK at least), so perhaps not ideal for an international book club, but I would certainly recommend you, trunky-wunky, reading lady of the flowers.

Books that are easily available: Finnegan's Wake. How about reading that kids? Eh? Eh?

golden child 05.17.2006 08:56 AM

ive read finnegans wake
dumbest book ever

see post #21 for more info

Glice 05.17.2006 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golden child
ive read finnegans wake
dumbest book ever

see post #21 for more info


I take issue with use of the word 'dumbest' - perhaps you're confusing the word 'dumbest' with 'best'?

But no, all joking aside, it's a terrible idea, I love that book more than any other, but it is utterly ridiculous to expect other people to enjoy what is the most deeply unreadable book I can think of (with Derrida's 'Glas' and 'of Grammatology' coming in in 2nd and 3rd place respectively)

Rob Instigator 05.17.2006 09:27 AM

I would love to join a book club.

there are many ways to do it. you could have a circle, where you pass 6 books around 6 people, and just go around...
lots of ideas.

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 05.17.2006 09:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truncated
I can't believe I paid money to sit in a classroom and listen to a group of naive, pompous fucks expounding upon the symbolism of monkey heads in "Woman Warrior" and stroking each other's cerebral cocks. Because frankly, if you need someone else to point these things out to you, you're a lost cause anyhow, and you should put the book down before you even bother to begin it.


Haha. I read Woman Warrior, errr, I read the first 1/3rd and skimmed the rest. My main comment on the book was that I understood what she meant in the first part because my aunt comitted suicide. It seemed very Oprah Book-clubish to me though, so I gave my copy to my Mom and she liked it.

SpectralJulianIsNotDead 05.17.2006 09:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golden child
some books im interested in reading, these are books i own but havent read yet and will be reading soon regardles...

tropic of cancer - henry miller
the idiot - fydor dostoyevsky (too long?)
notes from the underground - fydor dostoyesvsky
anything by kafka
anna karenin - tolstoy
democracy in america - alexis de tocqueville
a farewell to arms - ernest hemingway
a modern instance - william d howells
the republic - plato
neuromancer - william gibson
battlefield earth - l ron hubbard (long)


The problem with that list is about half those books a lot of people have read or will read anyways.

truncated 05.17.2006 09:35 AM

If Genet is difficult to obtain for you UK folks, an alternative I would suggest is something by Naguib Mahfouz (ignore any postmodern tags that may be applied to him). Culturally educational, excellent prose style, and entertaining. Just a thought, though I'd opt for Genet first.

Savage Clone 05.17.2006 09:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truncated
I know you didn't just knock Stephen King.



Hack.

truncated 05.17.2006 10:20 AM

Your cruelty is astounding.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:17 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth